So how ‘should’ we collect a child’s authentic voice? EHCP Part A

In November I attended the conference ‘Two Years of Education Health and Care Plans: Are we there Yet?’ at the University of Roehampton where the results of a research project on the quality of Education Health and Care plans (EHCP) were presented, and implications for children, families, professionals and policy was discussed. A large focus of that conference was Part A, and research presented on the likely authenticity or otherwise of the child’s voice. It raised many questions for me which I blogged about Here. However, it did lead me to better consider how I might get my son’s authentic voice for Part A and Secondary Transfer.

I believed that asking a child with ASD/ADHD and an expressive Language Disorder (who had never been in a Secondary school), to give their views about their future to a relative professional stranger, requesting this information according to their own school visit schedule, was unlikely to produce an authentic voice. I was already aware of my beliefs that a voice is never isolated but is embedded in relationships, negotiation and perspective.

I also believed that that a child’s wishes and dreams can’t be caught in a moment but will be expressed over time and during intimate moments with people they love and trust. Therefore, I set to collect statements my son made through these many interactions, discussions and sharing of worries, and recorded them in real time in a notebook or on my phone.

When I felt I had enough (and the deadline from the Local Authority was pressing) I typed up the statements and printed them out, cutting them into strips to be sorted by my son under three headings. ‘Need’, ‘Want’ and ‘Don’t Care’. I left him in peace to decide for himself and made no judgements when I returned.

IMG_1292

When that was completed, we focused on just the category of ‘Need’ and with ‘Most Important’ at the top and ‘Least Important’ at the bottom, my son ordered the list of statements. Again, I made no comments and my son seemed to enjoy the task and the feeling that he could have some say in what he thought he needed without anyone demanding that he use language he finds difficult.

IMG_1299

It was interesting to find out that the top 3 Needs as identified by him were ‘A school where everyone understands all about me’, ‘Where there are school trips to Italy’, and ‘Where I can get qualifications to have my own house with 2 rooms and go to my job’.

Because we were no longer working from a blank slate or an abstract concept where he was expected to come up with ideas from nowhere or make anxiety-inducing big decisions about his future, I was then able to ask if there was anything missing that he’d like to include. He added at the very top: ‘To find going to school every day fantastic’ and ‘I need a school that does very well and treats me in the way I like and understands me, like my school now’.

Brilliant basis on which to build his Outcomes for Part E, I’m sure you’d agree.

 

 

 

 

 

Advertisements

13 thoughts on “So how ‘should’ we collect a child’s authentic voice? EHCP Part A

  1. Great idea. Over the past few months I’ve also been doing a lot of scribing of ideas of what my girl wants from a school. Even when communication is a challenge, there’s usually always feelings there – you just have to listen and watch a little harder for them!

    Like

  2. we used photos, my son chose what was important or simply liked by him. Speech & written language are not so accessible for him. I tried to compliment it with carefully making note of his reactions to certain things that EHCP plan needed to include

    Like

  3. Think this is really interesting and makes a change from the forms we have received with the same questions/same language as before but put into cute speech bubbles as if that makes them easier for a child to understand! The sorting approach is really good I think – I took a similar approach when researching transition (from special school to mainstream college) with young people with autism and we had a sorting activity with statements on an iPad app to identify things they were worried about and things they were looking forward to. For less verbal students then photos/pictures really helpful and we also used an iPad collage activity to identify their strengths and what they liked best at school. I do think that for children who are pre-verbal or extremely unlikely to use it with a stranger (!) then it is incumbent on us as parents but also as professionals in health, care and education to use our imagination and work a bit harder to think about how we try to capture views of disabled children. And I absolutely agree about parents scaffolding communication – and they also know through all sorts of ways how the child communicates whether they are happy or not. Language is not the only fruit!

    Like

  4. Come late to this post … authentic voice for transition was valuable for our son who is deaf and who wanted a deaf peer group for sixth form.

    With his permission I took a selection of posts from his Facebook page and put them into a 4 minute PowerPoint set to music for the LA Moderating panel members. These included memes, comments, photos etc to show his desire to go to University, his love of mountain biking etc, his fears (people with disabilities being bullied), his humour ( jokes) and his obvious Deaf identity. These were his posts over the previous year. The LA senco said it was really helpful.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s